|

QUBEview case studies provide an insightful summary of the
key issues and trends across a range of exposures.
Using our QUBEview cases, we take the opportunity to share
our insights on cases that have occurred and exposures that,
potentially, could impact on you.
Many insurance advisers and clients find that our QUBEview
cases provide a convenient way to tap into the expertise provided
by the QBE New Zealand team in each specialist division.
Case Study Archive:
|
|
|
Exposures Are Plenty when Ship
Runs Aground
March 2002
Abstract: On the evening of 6 February
2002, huge swells surged into Poverty Bay, causing bulk
log carrier Jody F Millennium to break free from her
moorings. The 5m swells were the biggest to hit the
Gisborne area in a decade.
|
| |
|
|
|
Manage the Risks Then
Relax Over the Holidays
November 2001
Abstract: It is the end of a challenging
year, and you are enjoying a well deserved break over
the Christmas period. Perhaps you are out fishing or
relaxing at the family batch. Then the phone rings,
breaking the peace and bringing bad news. The site you
are completing your latest project on has been trashed
and deliberately set fire to.
|
| |
|
|
|
Increase in Extreme Weather Increases
Damage and Delays
May 2001
Abstract: During the past year New
Zealand has been exposed to many extreme weather events.
These extreme weather events have caused significant
damage not only to existing structures but to projects
in the course of construction. Damage ranges from roofs
being dislodged to concrete being damaged prior to full
curing.
|
| |
|
|
|
Standard Project Specific Insurance
Not Enough
October 2000
Abstract: A recent decision by the
Queensland Court of Appeal has highlighted the need
for developers, builders and sub contractors to have
an annual general liability policy rather than just
a project specific liability policy.
|
| |
|
|
|
Bad
Form Not Limited to Cricket
April
2000
Abstract:
On a construction job heavy rain causes subsidence in
the ground, and freshly laid concrete to slump. Problems
in construction aren't always foreseeable or immediately
detectable. But early detection and action can however
save a lot of time and money. In this instance, technical
advice from an engineer was needed to immediately save
the formwork, repair the site, and to maintain the momentum
of the project.
|
| |
|
|
|
And
the Wall Comes a Tumblin' Down
April
2000
Abstract:
Towards the end of a project a wall on a construction
site is toppled by wind gusts causing costly delays
and repair. Every construction site is vulnerable to
many dangers, including storms. Ugly weather can disrupt
schedules and inflict damage in a few moments. It's
vital that builders have the right cover in place from
day one, come rain or shine.
|
| |
|
|
|
The
Dangers of Signwriting
March
2000
Abstract:
A former supermarket sign and ticket writer is considering
taking legal action against her former employer for
neglecting to stop her forming an addiction to solvents.
The case demonstrates that gradual process exposures
aren't immediately detectable and highlights that it
is vital employers have adequate liability cover.
|
| |
|
|
|
Huge
OOS Exposure Looms in the Workplace
March
2000
Abstract:
An exemplary damages award in 1998 has, at least, cracked
open the flood gates for staff seeking damages from
their employers due to Occupational Overuse Syndrome.
|
| |
|
|
|
Trench
Collapse Costs Construction Man
March
2000
Abstract:
A project manager in Dunedin was fined after an employee
was injured in a trench mishap that also caught him
in the same landslide. Unfortunately deaths in the construction
industry are not rare and the prosecuting bodies are
increasingly taking a hard line view when prosecuting.
|
| |
|
|
|
Weird
Accident Costs Manufacturer $57,000
March
2000
Abstract:
A "burst-proof" container that "wasn't"
cost a Penrose resin manufacturer tens of thousands
of dollars in fines, legal and cleanup costs. Freak
accidents occur and when they affect the environment,
"Clean, Green" New Zealand Councils react
quickly and with force, aided by the Resource Management
Act 1991. This incident also has public liability ramifications
and highlights the need to have a complete liability
programme.
|
| |
|
|
|
Fatal
Face Peel Leads to $12,500 Fine
March
2000
Abstract:
The company that imported and advertised a face-peeling
product was fined a total of $12,500 for five charges
of selling and advertising medicine that had not been
approved. The importer, principal shareholder and doctor
were all charged, demonstrating how numerous parties
can be dragged into a single action.
|
| |
|
|
|
Killer
Playgrounds?
March
2000
Abstract:
A North Shore City Council report reveals that one third
of the playground equipment in the North Shore do not
comply with their safety standards. If a child were
injured whilst playing on the equipment that the Council
knew was unsafe, the Council would be exposed to potentially
huge exemplary damages. Businesses who knew of faulty
equipment that someone was injured on would also find
themselves exposed to exemplary damages.
|
| |
|
|
|
Dust
Blown' in the Wind Costs $28,500
March
2000
Abstract:
A property developer and earthworks contractor face
fines of $28,500 following last October's dust storms
at a Papamoa sub division after breaching dust control
rules. The case shows how an insured party can find
itself defending actions on several fronts - in this
case public and statutory liability.
|
| |
|
|
|
Huge
Implications in Mental Trauma Settlement
March
2000
Abstract:
The Danes Shotover Rafts Ltd v Palmer Case. An American
man wins a significant mental trauma settlement after
his witnessing the drowning of his wife in the Shotover
River. The settlement demonstrates that there may be
implications for all businesses as anyone who sees a
tragedy may have grounds to sue. There are no judicial
guidelines as to how much New Zealand courts will award
a plaintiff suffering nervous shock.
|
| |
|
|
|
New
Exposure to Exemplary Damages for Personal Injury
January
1999
Abstract:
If you cause a personal, injury the injured person may
be able to claim against you for exemplary damages.
If you have been dealt with under criminal law, the
law no longer prevents the victim from suing you for
exemplary damages, irrespective of whether or not the
police have charged the offender, the court has heard
the case or convicted (or acquitted) the defendant.
QBE Public Liability and Employers' Liability policies
include cover for exemplary damages.
|
| |
|
|
|
Right
to Sue for Mental Injury Revived
March
1999
Abstract:
In a landmark case, Danes Shotover Rafts v Palmer, the
Court of Appeal has ruled that the ACC laws do not bar
a person who has suffered mental injury only from suing
for compensation. QBE specifically introduces its Employers'
Liability Policy to respond to such situations.
|
| |
|